Restaurants

When Does Penny's Bagels Open in Haddonfield? What We Know About the Kings Highway Shop

A sign in the window says end of November. The job posts are up. The official date isn't, yet.

By Live Haddonfield ·

fresh everything, poppy seed and plain bagels on a wooden board with bowls of cream cheese and a latte

Penny's Bagels, the long-awaited bagel shop at 212 Kings Highway East, is aiming to open at the end of November, according to a sign on the storefront reported by South Jersey Food Scene on Nov. 8. There's still no official opening date. But the shop posted job openings for its first crew on Nov. 13, which is about as good a sign as a sign gets.

Here's what we know, and what we don't.

The opening date: end of November, maybe

South Jersey Food Scene peeked inside and said the space "looks just about ready to go." A source close to the project told the site a date "should be announced pretty soon."

This one has slipped before. In September, WhatNow Philadelphia reported the shop was aiming for an October debut, citing The Philadelphia Inquirer. October came and went. WhatsOpening still lists it as "opening unconfirmed."

So: plan on soon. Don't plan your Saturday around it yet.

Who's behind it

Penny's comes from Chris Fetfatzes and Happy Monday Hospitality, per WhatNow. The group runs Philadelphia bars including Sonny's, Grace & Proper and WineDive. The company's website lists Penny's as "Coming Soon."

What's on the menu

Details are thin. The shop's social media points to homemade bagels in plain, everything and poppy, plus schmears, under the tagline "Be a dear, add a schmear," WhatNow reported. The hiring post adds creative sandwiches, coffee and espresso drinks, and grab-and-go orders.

Want a job there?

The Nov. 13 listing seeks counter team members and baristas for the opening team, full-time and part-time, at $17 an hour plus tips. Staff will be cross-trained on the register and the coffee bar. Applications are open through Dec. 13.

The sign went to Historic Preservation

Downtown storefronts need sign approval. Penny's redesigned sign was on the Historic Preservation Commission's Nov. 12 agenda, as we noted in our preview of that week's public meetings.

More bagels downtown

Penny's won't be the only bagel in town. Fishtown Seafood in Haddonfield added bagels in early November. We also covered Penny's missed October target there. Catch up in our Haddonfield restaurant news roundup.

We'll update when Penny's names a day. The Friday newsletter is the easiest way to hear first when a new spot opens in town. Subscribe here.

FAQ

When does Penny's Bagels open?
No official date has been announced. A storefront sign targets the end of November, per South Jersey Food Scene on Nov. 8.
Where is Penny's Bagels?
212 Kings Highway East in downtown Haddonfield.
Is Penny's Bagels hiring?
Yes. A job post dated Nov. 13 seeks counter staff and baristas for the opening team at $17 an hour plus tips.

Sources

Get Live Haddonfield in your inbox

The best of life in 08033, every Friday. Free.

Subscribe on Substack

More from Food & Drink